Of large carnivores and humans
each civilisation has a different attitude towards nature and wildlife. And one of the best indicators of how a culture relates to the environment is its attitude towards large carnivores, who are not only an important factor in maintaining the ecological equilibrium but also a source of potential conflicts and danger to people and cattle. The relationships of the Europeans with wolves and their counterparts in India with tigers provide a good picture of these concepts.
Conquerors and exterminators In Europe, people have tried to destroy the wolf since the Middle Ages. In many countries, such as England, France and Germany, wolves have been exterminated completely. The European colonies in the Americas continued this war, killing millions of wolves in a short period. Even in other Western countries, such as Portugal, Spain and Italy, wolves have been persecuted, their number reduced to near extinction. But the species has survived.
One of the few places in western Europe where wolves still survive is the Montesinho Natural Park in north-eastern Portugal. It is a hilly area of about 750 sq km with a Mediterranean climate. Forests and scrubs cover more than 50 per cent of the area, the rest being agricultural land. Over the centuries, people have destroyed native forests, cut trees for wood and burnt the scrubs to make provisory pastures. About 30 wolves still howl here, preying mainly on wild boar, roe deer, red deer and domestic sheep and goats.
These wolves are not isolated, as their population is in contact with neighbouring ones in Spain and other areas around the park, shaping the biggest wolf population in western Europe.
About 8,000 people live in 92 little villages inside the park. In these villages, the human population is decreasing. In village Varge, about 50 per cent of the people have migrated. Almost all villagers are farmers and shepherds. Each family owns an average of 15 hectares of land, mostly comprising small, irrigated fields near the village and larger dry fields, pastures and forest. The main commercial crops are cereals and chestnuts. The shepherds, one or two in every village, graze about 250 sheep each and some goats. The average income per family is us $500 per month.
The villagers have a very limited knowledge about wolves and many have strange beliefs. Some believe that wolves have poisonous fangs, while others feel that wolves do not prey on wild boar, that the boar is in fact stronger than the former and they kill and eat wolf cubs. They have an inverted image of the ecological pyramid, placing the wild boar at the very top.
When the villagers come across wolves, they try to scare them away, set their dogs after them or light fires. Due to centuries of persecution, the wolves have developed a strong fear of humans. Most of the contacts between villagers and wolves occur when wolves attack domestic herds. But these are relatively rare. In fact, in the Varge village, wolves kill less than 0.1 per cent of the livestock each year. They also prey on dogs, and sometimes enter the villages to hunt them. But these cases are rare. During the past few decades, the attacks on livestock have decreased as the number of wild herbivores has increased. The park, however, pays good indemnities for the loss of livestock. As for people, wolves have not attacked any person in the region this century.
When a sheep or a person is lost on the hills, the villagers utter the responsos , special and secret prayers to Saint Antonio, in order to give them supernatural protection. Some carry the Bible when they walk alone on the hills at night. Once a year the priest blesses the livestock to protect it against infirmities and wolf attacks. In the past, people believed in the existence of werewolves. According to legend, certain people could acquire a wolf's appearance, attacking and terrifying people. The wolf used to symbolise evil all over Europe. In some regions, it still does. The villagers near the natural park even resorted to poisoning entire wolf packs.
However, not everyone is against these creatures. There are still a few people living in the park who consider wolves useful and that they need to be protected. According to them wolves control populations of wild herbivores, such as the wild boar that destroy the crops. Ironically, this is the main reason why many think that wolves should be exterminated.
To ensure the survival of the wolf and other wild animals, an environmental education campaign is needed in the region. The rural people believe nature is a force that must be dominated, eradicating all the wild animals that cause damage. This attitude was typical among the Europeans until recent years, and was supported by the Catholic Church, politicians and intellectuals, and the fallout of this thinking is evident in the destruction of fauna and ecosystems in Europe and countries that were colonised by Europeans.
Living with the tiger On the other side of the world, in the Sariska Tiger Reserve in the western Indian state of Rajasthan, villagers have a completely different attitude towards large carnivores. Within the 800 sq km reserve, about 10-20 tigers, a few panthers and thousands of large herbivores, such as nilgai , sambar and wild boar, coexist with 16 little villages. Most of this hilly area is covered by dry deciduous forest and the climate is dry tropical.
In villages like Haripura, about 150 people of the Gujjar community live in 21 families. Their houses are made of indigenous materials. There is no electricity, running water or toilets in these villages. For vehicles, they have only bicycles. More than 70 per cent of them are illiterate. Each family grazes buffaloes for their milk. Most families have a monthly income of about Rs 2,000-4,000 ( us $65-130), mostly from selling milk. They are humble but not miserable. Being lacto-vegetarians, milk and purchased cereals and vegetables form their basic food. They also pick wild grain and fruit, such as ber , mostly for self-consumption. They consume small quantities of firewood
Related Content
- Habitat use of tigers and leopards, and habitat connectivity in the Bandhavgarh-Sanjay Corridor
- A future for all: the need for human-wildlife coexistence
- Insights from distribution dynamics inform strategies to conserve a dhole Cuon alpinus metapopulation in India
- Leopard in a tea-cup: A study of leopard habitat-use and human-leopard interactions in north-eastern India
- Human behaviour can trigger large carnivore attacks in developed countries
- Large carnivore and prey status in Phen Wildlife Sanctuary, Madhya Pradesh, India