Community participation emerged as the defining principle of forest policies all over the world in the closing decades of the last century. In India, this came about after the Indian forest policies went through different stages from largely commercial-centric to a community-oriented approach. The access to forests and participation in their management has always been a bone of contention between the state agencies and the local communities. The colonial forest policy of the British and the first forest policy of independent India systematically curtailed the traditional rights and role of forest-dependent communities while claiming to address community demands. After a long and continuous denial of the crucial stake that local communities have in their nearby forests, it was only in late 1980s that they were accorded some space. While the current policies seem to be advancing communities’ role in forest management, yet there are several bottlenecks in terms of their implementation. The dominant role of the forest department, failure to involve community as an equal partner, weak institutional mechanism and inadequate legal back up, among other factors, have obstructed the satisfactory execution of the policies. This article is a critical overview of the changing paradigms of successive forest policies in India and argues that the real participation of the community can be ensured only when it is accorded a meaningful stake in all forest matters affecting the community.