Individual or species? Animal rights or animal welfare?

  • 03/04/2008

  • Hindu

During a short visit to Australia last month, I witnessed a heated debate between the Defence Department officials and animal activists. The former wanted to cull the kangaroo colony that was growing at an alarming rate in their office campus at Canberra. The activists thought the very idea a sacrilege. The government's predicament is only a small replica of what is happening in much of Australia. Less food and fodder Apparently there are far more kangaroos in the island continent than people. They forage and reproduce incessantly leading to an alarming drop in grassland. This has resulted in less food and fodder for the cattle and other livestock. And soil degradation is getting worse, eating up productivity. The larger question being debated is whether the kangaroo population should be culled down to a manageable level, so that both the animals and the environment can be comfortable and sustainable. Ten thousand miles west in South Africa is a similar problem. As kangaroos are dear to the Aussies, wildebeest and elephants are to the Proteans. The Krueger National Park there houses and takes good care of elephants. A bit too good